Thomas was just pointing out another big mistake by Schneider

Earl flippingWhen Earl Thomas gave his one-finger salute to John Schneider (who else would he be targeting?) as the safety was being carted off the field Sunday in Arizona, he was just pointing out the general manager’s latest error.

Earlier this year, we detailed many of the mistakes Schneider has made since his magical (lucky?) draft run from 2010 to 2012. It has merely continued this year, with the Thomas debacle now officially another black eye for Schneider and the Rashaad Penny pick looking every bit the waste it appeared in April.

We are on the record as saying Schneider needed to re-sign Thomas or just take a second-rounder for him. Thomas publicly backed either play, too, and his “you’re the one” salute to Schneider (who had to be his specific target on the sideline) as he was carted off with a broken leg was kind of an exclamation point on Schneider’s failure there.

Dallas reportedly had offered a second-round pick during training camp, but Schneider had held firm on getting more. Then an report Monday indicated Schneider finally had come off his price and was ready to deal Thomas to Kansas City for a second-rounder. Per the report, that deal might not have been consummated for another week or two (the deadline is Oct. 30), but Schneider waited way too long to lower his price.

It’s the same mistake he made with Richard Sherman in 2017, refusing to lower his demand and then watching Sherman suffer a major injury and lose any trade value. Schneider then simply dumped the cantankerous Sherman and his big salary — getting nothing in return. The GM should have taken the 2 — or even Jarvis Landry — when he had the chance. Poor business move.

And now he has done the same thing with Thomas, failing to maximize his return for the safety because he was too stubborn for too long. Thomas now will leave in free agency next year, and the best the Seahawks will get is a possible third-round comp pick in 2020. If his broken leg diminishes his market value, he might merit only a fourth-rounder. And, if Schneider does as he did this year and adds more UFAs than he loses, Thomas will not bring any return at all. It’s just more bad business by the GM.

As for the raging debate about Thomas’ “No. 1” salute, of course it was poor form. Thomas chose to return to play (he wanted his $500,000 weekly salary), so he cannot blame anyone for his injury. But we completely agree with Thomas that he should have been re-signed or traded long ago.

As for Penny, the first-round pick has played second/third string all season. In Arizona, he ran behind Mike Davis, who scored twice and recorded Seattle’s second straight 100-yard rushing day by a tailback.

Pete Carroll explained the decision: “I talked it over with Schotty (Brian Schottenheimer) about who we thought would handle it the best and would be the most comfortable. Mike’s played more and he’s been around and started games and all that. We just thought we’d go that way and keep Rashaad kind of in the role that we had projected going into the game, where he would come in off the bench and fill in and do some stuff, and we would see how the game would go.”

Penny ran well in his limited tries — 49 yards on nine rushes — but it seems clear the first-round pick will remain a backup runner while now returning kicks (he ran back three for 65 yards at Arizona).

As everyone except Schneider and Carroll knows, Penny was a big reach in the first round — and it has been confirmed by the fact that he is a mere role player instead of the starter. Yet another poor decision by Schneider, who has made plenty of them the last few years.


3 thoughts on “Thomas was just pointing out another big mistake by Schneider”

  1. The erosion of the wide receiver corps stands out to me. By draft:

    2013: Chris Harper (4)
    2014: Paul Richardson (2), Kevin Norwood (4)
    2015: Tyler Lockett (3)
    2016: Kenny Lawler (7)
    2017: Amara Darboh (3), David Moore (7)

    It’s not like they haven’t invested — a 2, a 3, and two 4’s ought to yield more than one overpaid, oft-injured starter. And it’s an open question whether Doug Baldwin will be the same player — a knee injury to a WR whose game is predicated around getting off the line does not bode well.

    Note: This year, the combined salaries Golden Tate and Jermaine Kearne ($12.5M) will be 1.5M more than Tyler Lockett’s haul ($11M). Lockett is having a nice season, but he’s no Tate by a long shot.


  2. Great article! Hindsight is always 20/20. Obviously the trade value was not right and the team avoided huge payouts and salary cap hell by not paying these guys long term. I say JS made the right decisions.


  3. I think Lockett is great. He doesn’t get the targets in Seattle that Tate gets in Detroit, just like Tate didn’t get as many throws in Seattle as he does now. Both excellent receivers. Tate wasn’t retained largely because of Percy Harvin.

    The Darboh failure above really stands out to me. P-Rich couldn’t stay healthy early in his career, and Hawks preferred to pay Lockett. I’m with that move.

    Overall, I think the Hawks will be fine at receiver unless Baldwin ends up sidelined again. Moore and Brown need to get into the action more, over butter-hands Marshall …


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s